Safari is Old Browser - BBC Leave Steve Jobs Alone
Aug 05
No Cut option in Mac Finder

Cut Option in Windows

There already has been a long debate about Mac’s Finder without the Cut option for folders. Cut option is enabled while working in TextEdit to cut the text but the same Cut option seems disabled for folders inside Finder. I use Cut very frequently in my Windows machine but i am missing such flexibility of file moving in Mac. Cut basically is similar to Move function but in “Move” i have to drag the folder to the destination . With “Cut” the process becomes very fast. I think in Cut what extra is given over to Move is , Cut just keeps the path of the Cut Folder in Clipboard/temporary memory and when pasted somewhere else the foder/file is moved from the Clipboard location to the destination. Programatically Cut shouldn’t be any problem for Mac developers but still its not there . I dont understand why. This should easily be done through AppleScript . I dont have knowledge of AppleScript but when i learn it , the first thing i will do would be to create a AppleScript for Cut and Paste. So till now Cut paste is availabe in Apple Mac but it includes two steps ;-) . Oh there already is a scrip here but i cant seem to get that work on my Leopard. The two steps for Cut in Mac are

1. Copy the folder to destination ( takes longer time than Cut in windows because contents should be duplicated )

2. Delete the folder/file from original location

Apple’s apparent philosophy here is that it would be confusing to the user if they were to cut a file in the filesystem, then cut something else (such as text from a document) without having first pasted the cut file (where does the file go?). To avoid this situation, Apple has opted to prevent the user from using cut in the filesystem entirely. Unforunately, this means that if you want to move a file from one location to another using the keyboard, you’ll need to copy the file, paste it into its new location, and then delete the original file.

There is a Script which enables Cut Option for folders in Finder window but this only moves the folder to Trash. No paste option is available after Cut. And to have the Script Menu bar extras available in the Apple menu bar like shown below in image we need to activate Script Menu.menu file by double clicking the file which is located at Apple Drive>System>Library>CoreServices>Menu Extras .

There also is an utility called Finder Cut & Paste which does the work . This utility is basically the applescript ( but works  the previous script didn’t work for me). To have key combination for Cut and Paste like in Windows , we can use Spark

The nearest built-in solution to Cut optin i have found is related to Spring loaded folders which makes the Move process Animated and little easy . But this is no way equivalent to Cut but comes closer . Below is the Video about how to use Spring loaded folders inbuilt in Mac.

Click to Play

Related entries you may like to read !

64 Responses to “No Cut option in Mac Finder Window”

  1. Wendy SINGAPORE Says:

    With the help of Exposé, I don’t find it’s hard to move files from one place to another. But still, Windows switchers will find it’s really difficult to live without Cut option.

  2. MacPhobia HONG KONG Says:

    Expose is one Good thing i like in Mac . It sure makes Moving of files or folder easier but not as easy as it is with Cut and paste . In cut and paste there is no dragging , no mouse freezing

  3. Akash UNITED STATES Says:

    i’m not able to enable cut/paste option you explained.when i try to run it,an error is generated like this:Can’t make “Macintosh HD:Users:akashjain:Library:Preferences:CutAppleScript Prefs” into type specifier.

  4. MacPhobia HONG KONG Says:

    Hello Akash, Did you use this utility found here. http://www.versiontracker.com/dyn/moreinfo/macosx/30250

  5. MacTipper UNITED STATES Says:

    Yeah, I’m totally self-promoting, but I think I have one of the cleanest solutions out there:

    http://www.mactipper.com/2008/09/cutpaste-in-finderapp.html

    Basically, I use a Service in conjunction with a keyboard shortcut (Cmd-X of course) to mimic cut in Finder. Enjoy!

  6. Alex UNITED STATES Says:

    Great utility MacTipper. Thanks!

  7. Janakiram AUSTRALIA Says:

    In mac with out cut option we can forgo. There is no need of cut in mac because we always use drag and drops in mac. Mac is a Gorgeous OS.

  8. haha... UNITED STATES Says:

    haha… janakarim! love the sarcasm. :)

  9. vishaal CANADA Says:

    Apple could just have a beep if you try and paste a ‘cut’ item from its clipboard to somewhere it can’t go permanently.

    beep!?

    Seems like an easy fix that isn’t too confusing.

  10. aces TAIWAN Says:

    the most absent feature in mac is the right click->cut (on files and folders),

    i wonder who is the jerk in apple that is keeping us from getting this feature,

    PathFinder is a good replacement for Finder and it has cut feature,
    but it lacks several features that the new Finder in leopard has, for instance Cover-Flow, quick look etc.

    1. open terminal and write this line:
    defaults write com.apple.finder AllowCutForItems 1

    2. restart Finder, in terminal write:
    killall Finder
    or
    right click dock finder icon with option button pressed (Alt/WinKey in hackintosh) and choose “relaunch”

    to undo this simply execute the same lines only this time replace the value 1 with 0 like this:
    defaults write com.apple.finder AllowCutForItems 0
    killall Finder

  11. Rob UNITED STATES Says:

    Aces: That is good, but it doesn’t seem to make the file available for pasting. It only trashes the file. :(

  12. Franklin Dattein BRAZIL Says:

    The property “com.apple.finder AllowCutForItems” doesn’t work. The ‘cut’ command it enables, is actually a ’send to trash’ command. Odd!

  13. rickcr UNITED STATES Says:

    ZERO excuse to not allow file cut & paste (and I’m a Mac user who loves his mac.) For one, I’d also argue it’s a BILLION times safer than trying to teach someone how to correctly drag and drop to move items. When you have directories that are large that you have to wait to spring load etc - drag and drop is a pain and often you’ll ”unclick” at the wrong spot, or realize you’re in the wrong directory and have to ‘unclick’ somewhere safe and start over. I’ve watched my parents try to keep the left click pressed the whole time while trying to drag things with a mouse and it’s not nearly that easy as telling them ‘”highlight what you want to move. Select cut.” Now take your time and find the folder where you want to add the item. Then click “paste.”

    As a side note in all OSs, I wish the default behavior of “pasting” when you have selected a folder is to paste the item “IN” the folder you have selected. Too often the behavior is to paste the item at the same level directory you are at, which I do not find intuitive.

  14. adit INDONESIA Says:

    thank’s for the great app, i worked well in my Leopard

    at the first time i thought it didn’t work, because i used cmd+x and cmd-v… but how fortunate i am, in comments above i noticed the approprate way to do “cut & paste” is push cmd-x twice

  15. traxexx INDONESIA Says:

    Hold Command and Drag file to move

  16. herpderp SWEDEN Says:

    You DO NOT put a space before a dot or a comma. There we go.

  17. Dens PHILIPPINES Says:

    @ traxexx

    sir thanks for that advice, my mac has been with me for almost a year now, and i finally know the option or at least something similar to “cut”… thanks again for the shortcut!

  18. Hugo Syms 173.180.215.21 not found Says:

    I forgot to mention that FileCutter works with Leopard but unfortunately it is not compatible with Snow Leopard.

  19. Clank UNITED STATES Says:

    The reason Apple does not make a Cut option: It’s too dangerous for an average user. Apple tries their best to make sure the user can not shoot themselves in the foot. What if someone cuts and never pastes? What happens to the file? It’s a safety thing.

    But for regular folks like Us, it’s kinda lame. You have to keep going back to delete the original because it wont cut.

    For the longest time I wondered why the Mac OS is stupid simple. Then I saw Apple Store employes training a bunch of old farts and it all makes since now.

  20. Steve_largent UNITED STATES Says:

    What if someone cuts and never pastes? What happens to the file?

    ^^
    the file just remains in the original folder.

  21. Anthony AUSTRALIA Says:

    @Clank: Nothing happens to the file if you don’t paste it, since Windows doesn’t do anything to it is until you paste it somewhere. Even if you put normal text onto the clipboard, Windows just aborts the cut/paste operation on the file and it stays where it is.

  22. Divor AUSTRALIA Says:

    This ‘feature” annoys me every day. I’ve been a mac user for several years now, and I’m still not used to not having a cut function for files and folders. As Steve_largent points out, there is no ‘problem’ to begin with.

  23. Hugo Syms 173.183.73.252 not found Says:

    I posted a link to an application that adds a ‘cut’ feature to the contextual menu.

    It still says “awaiting moderation”, next to my username (this was posted over a month ago). Any mods out there??

    But if you do a search for FileCutter and Mac it should lead you in the right direction.

  24. polocanada CANADA Says:

    I hope Apple will ad an option in control panel to select (enable) cut/past style in finder or select (enable) classic mac “move” style in finder. That way both folks can learn co-exist peacefully. That’s not such a complicated thing to do for Mac. I can’t get it they haven’t done it yet. Same thing with iPhone copy past function, it took so long for Apple to implement it.

  25. TWO UNITED KINGDOM Says:

    You know what? When I first switched to Mac, i thought this was the most ridiculous thing ever. But, as with anything, you learn to use the features that are present. It isn’t difficult to understand that all one need do to cut (move) a file is to drag it do the destination of choice. If you want to cut from one medium to another, simply click cmd as you drag the file to the destination.

    Every operating system does the same thing, it’s just about getting accustomed to its method.

  26. Phil ITALY Says:

    I use cut and paste all the time on my PC. On my mac I am reduced to tears at the stupidity of the interface designers. If the only issues are …
    “it would be confusing to the user if they were to cut a file in the filesystem, then cut something else (such as text from a document) without having first pasted the cut file (where does the file go?)”
    or
    “What if someone cuts and never pastes? What happens to the file?”
    …then just rename the commands to “move file from here” and “move file to here”.
    And if it is still too difficult for some people to manage, why not have the presence of these commands as an opt in option in system preferences.
    That way the OS will be useful to us who use the computer with both hands, instead of only to those who keep one hand on the mouse and one hand on something entirely different.

  27. Mark ITALY Says:

    I can’t believe Mac users still think that if you cut a file in Windows, then cut something else without pasting the first one, it DOES NOT DISAPPEAR. The file is not moved until you select paste, if you cut a file then cut another one, the first one simply stays there because NOTHING HAPPENS TO THE FILE UNTIL YOU PASTE IT. It’s not like as soon as you select cut the files gets lifted to some temporary memory and disappears if you cut something else, they aren’t that stupid. The stupid ones are the guys at apple that have no freaking reason to not have cut for files and folders. As soon as I bought this mac I was surprised there was no cut for files, spring loaded folders and drag n drop are not a valid alternative to just selecting an option in a menu.

  28. Kee UNITED STATES Says:

    I respect the power and design of the macbook pro but… The OS… SUCKS!

    Sorry Apple.

    Awesome hardware though.

  29. a Martin SWEDEN Says:

    @Kee

    No, it doesn’t suck. Overall it’s more efficiant than Windows and other OSes, but of course you have to get used to it. Saying that Mac OS X sucks because it doesn’t do this and that exactly like in another OS is unfair. Then I can say the same for the other OSes that doesn’t behave exactly like Mac OS X. :/

  30. a Martin SWEDEN Says:

    @Kee

    No, it doesn’t suck. Overall I find it more efficient than Windows and other OSes, but of course you have to get used to it. Saying that Mac OS X sucks because it doesn’t do this and that exactly like in another OS is unfair. Then I can say the same for the other OSes that doesn’t behave exactly like Mac OS X. :/

  31. Videos FRANCE Says:

    Every operating system does the same thing, it’s just about getting accustomed to its method.

  32. get rid of cellulite naturally 188.26.204.252 not found Says:

    Cellulite sadly affects a lot of women, 90 percent to become exact. Some women partner the bothersome condition with being unsuitable and weight problems, a vast number of physically top fit women could also be affected by it because this occurs while they age and it’s also also of a less-than-healthy eating plan. With the country’s cottage-cheese-like overall look affecting this thighs, stomachs, calves, buttocks and waists of women all over the world; these women are dying to learn how to get rid of cellulite.

  33. Abram Sroka 74.82.173.214 not found Says:

    Thanks for the post. My spouse and i have continually observed that most people are eager to lose weight because they wish to show up slim along with attractive. Even so, they do not always realize that there are many benefits for you to losing weight also. Doctors claim that obese people suffer from a variety of diseases that can be perfectely attributed to their own excess weight. The good news is that people who are overweight and also suffering from various diseases are able to reduce the severity of their illnesses by way of losing weight. You’ll be able to see a constant but noticeable improvement with health when even a minor amount of losing weight is achieved gywl512.

  34. best-cellulite-products 69.162.164.235 not found Says:

    Hello, A very good post, I have to admit this is really well thought out, this forum definitely needs bloggers like you. Filling the forum with some good tips and information, I did follow A couple of your posts, they been relevant and nice points were elaborated. I must say we should always be prepared to post within our best knowledge to aid people. Really appreciate your posting.

  35. vizualgraphix UNITED STATES Says:

    Actually, there IS a way to cut or move files in OS X. Just hold down the CMD + SHFT keys, then drag-n-drop your file to the new location. It will automatically move your file from destination A to B.

  36. Shawnda Neddenriep BRAZIL Says:

    An attention-grabbing discussion is worth comment. I think that it’s best to write extra on this matter, it may not be a taboo topic but typically persons are not enough to speak on such topics. To the next. Cheers

  37. Purchase Backlinks 108.62.238.132 not found Says:

    Hi there! I know this is somewhat off topic but I was wondering if you knew where I could find a captcha plugin for my comment form? I’m using the same blog platform as yours and I’m having problems finding one? Thanks a lot!

  38. Kerry Kaniewski 14.222.31.133 not found Says:

    I know this if off topic but I’m looking into starting my own weblog and was wondering what all is needed to get setup? I’m assuming having a blog like yours would cost a pretty penny? I’m not very internet savvy so I’m not 100% positive. Any tips or advice would be greatly appreciated. Thank you

  39. Alexis Sutherlin UNITED STATES Says:

    You’re a very bright person!

  40. premium 31.214.139.42 not found Says:

    Good post. I be taught one thing more challenging on different blogs everyday. It’ll at all times be stimulating to read content material from other writers and observe slightly something from their store. I’d desire to make use of some with the content material on my weblog whether or not you don’t mind. Natually I’ll offer you a hyperlink on your internet blog. Thanks for sharing.

  41. bring the fresh full disclosure 184.168.152.191 not found Says:

    I really enjoyed reading this post.

  42. Canadian GAAP Vs IFRS BULGARIA Says:

    That famous quote comes to mind, “An intellectual improvement arises from leisure..”.

  43. Eduardo UNITED STATES Says:

    @vizualgraphix: You do realize that CMD+SHIFT isn’t really doing anything, right? if you’re dragging and dropping you don’t need to hold anything to move files.

  44. Dance Jazzy House R&B AUSTRALIA Says:

    Hi. I like browsing your blog. If you want to learn about Dance Jazzy House R&B check out my site!

  45. vizualgraphix UNITED STATES Says:

    @Eduardo: You would be correct, if you’re only considering moving files around on the internal drive. But if you have many partitions or additional internal/external drives, as I do with my Mac Pro, then drag-n-drop won’t suffice. In this case you MUST hold down CMD+SHFT in order to move files from A to B; otherwise it will just copy the files/folders and not remove them from their origin.

    Another scenario is if you’re a “limited user” (non-admin account) or have restricted access via permissions to a certain folder or drive. Then you would need to “authenticate” (enter an admin username and password) before you could copy or move files.

  46. Navier UNITED STATES Says:

    After 3 years of using Mac OS, another one I hate the Finder is that after you delete a file, the next one is not selected automatically. If the down arrow is pressed after delete a file, you’re all the way back to the top of the file list. Very bad behavior and Apple refused to fix this saying that’s a Mac feature. Yeah, right, why not try this feature on the email app: after an email is deleted, you’re brought all the way to the top of the email list to start scroll down again.

  47. JonathonDoh UNITED STATES Says:

    Having recently added OSX to the list of environments I use, I too find this lack of Cut to be annoying. In the Windows world, drag and drop behaves just like the OSX environment for those users who wish to use it that way (with the exception of which key to hold down when dropping). Even the other x-windows based shells that I have used, which run on various *nixes allow for the Cut feature should you wish to use it instead of drag and drop with a modifier key. Additionally, not to steer too far off-topic, I do really miss the complex click-shiftclick-controlclick-controlshiftclick form of multiselect that Windows provides; which is great for selecting subsets of files in folders where there are many files.

  48. prognoza pogody CHINA Says:

    Wow, amazing blog layout! How long have you been blogging for? you made blogging look easy. The inclusive look of your neighbourhood is great, leave to toute seule the fulfilled!

  49. Barclay VIET NAM Says:

    I’m thankful I discovered your blog on msn. Thanks for the sensible critique. My wife and me ended up being just preparing to study relating to this. I am very happy to see such great information getting shared freely out there.

  50. Addison VIET NAM Says:

    Whoa! Thanks! I always aspired to produce at my online site the like.

  51. Arthur Podeszwa 23.19.39.20 not found Says:

    Valuable info. Lucky me I found your site by accident, and I am shocked why this accident didn’t happened earlier! I bookmarked it.

  52. Maye Kopczyk 184.154.32.18 not found Says:

    Valuable info. Lucky me I found your web site by accident, and I am shocked why this accident didn’t happened earlier! I bookmarked it.

  53. Blake Corino 184.154.32.17 not found Says:

    whoah this blog is great i love reading your posts. Keep up the great work! You know, a lot of people are looking around for this info, you could help them greatly.

  54. Film x FRANCE Says:

    I think you can get every operating system to do this. The way is not different (totally)

  55. Jamie UNITED KINGDOM Says:

    Mac OS X Lion (10.7) now lets you do cut and paste in the Finder. Well, it’s actually “copy and move”, but that’s the same thing. Copy your file as usual, e.g. with Cmd-C. Go to where you want to move it to, and press Cmd-Opt-V (or hold down Option while using the Finder’s Edit menu).

    My usual method, however, is to drag. Watching some Windows users, you’d think it was only possible to have one Windows Explorer window open at a time. If you’re dragging between servers you have to hold down Command to force a move rather than a copy, similar to in Windows – although if I don’t trust the network I’ll usually copy the file then delete the original, just to be on the safe side.

  56. DanAtk UNITED KINGDOM Says:

    Yes, no cut and paste is a finder annoyance. Worse for me is the way folders are listed mixed in with files - how weird is that?

    Luckily help is at hand. Get a copy of TotalFinder on your Mac and you have keyboard cut/copy/paste of files, sorting of folders before files in list views, tabbed finder browsing and a few other nice features too.

    It is an essential Mac add-on for me.

  57. hex SPAIN Says:

    you CAN cut & paste in OSX, just follow these steps:

    1. select files in finder

    2. press left mouse button on any of these files icon

    3. drag to new location, DO NOT release mouse button yet

    4. either press OPTION key (leave source files untouched) or COMMAND key (delete source files after copying)

    5. release mouse button

    PS. if you dont press any key, OSX will leave source files untouched if destination is not on same volume as source, or delete them if destination is on same volume as source. i always press one key or the other, just to make my intention clear to the OS, plus its easier than trying to figure out beforehand what the OS is going to do.

  58. Andrew UNITED STATES Says:

    Props to Jaime for pointing out the simplest solution that equates to a Cut-Paste function on a Mac.

    Props to Hex for giving the detailed breakdown of what happens internally when the method is used.

  59. Michael UNITED STATES Says:

    WONDERFUL Post.thanks for share..more wait ..

  60. Bashar KUWAIT Says:

    Dude you must have noticed your floating bottom bar can drive person insane!

  61. asian full body massgae 69.172.211.91 not found Says:

    It is perfect time to make some plans for the future and it is time to be happy. I’ve read this post and if I could I desire to suggest you some interesting things or tips. Perhaps you can write next articles referring to this article. I want to read more things about it!

  62. sexy japanise massage 69.172.211.91 not found Says:

    Wonderful goods from you, man. I have understand your stuff previous to and you’re just too fantastic. I actually like what you have acquired here, certainly like what you’re stating and the way in which you say it. You make it entertaining and you still take care of to keep it sensible. I can not wait to read much more from you. This is actually a great website.

  63. sexy girl massage 108.62.202.39 not found Says:

    I think this is one of the most significant info for me. And i am glad reading your article. But should remark on few general things, The site style is great, the articles is really excellent : D. Good job, cheers

  64. Shiraz AUSTRALIA Says:

    in iOSx i.e Lion Past option is available for files and folder.

    select file (single click)
    press command + c (to copy the fie folder)
    in the destination folder/location
    press
    command + option + v (this will paste the file in destination folder and remove the file from source folder/location)

    enjoy trying

Leave a Reply